The Brier PatchThe Brier Patch
   
05.04.05
Too Much Information...

...or Three Mile Island

I just returned from some major debauchery here (photos below).

acc_ho_ext_001.jpg

acc_ho_ext_007.jpg

acc_ho_int_001.jpg


Business, real business…as in closing the damn bars every night. My ass is worn out, plain and simple.

I usually don’t sleep well in hotels, but the Hotel Hershey is different. They actually have comfortable beds with all the down. I’m down with the down. I slept like a drunken baby, but like I said, my ass is trashed. I get up with these people about once a year, and trying to squeeze 362 days into 3, is a "crash and burn" situation if I've ever seen one. Did I tell you, my ass is dead?

Anyway, to get there, you fly into Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, and the Three Mile Island Nuclear Plant is, literally, at the end of the runway. There are no federal regulations limiting how close you can fly to it. If there were, they'd have to shutdown the airport. No can do.

normal_TMI_14.jpg

Three Mile Island forced us to evaluate how groups of people react and make decisions under stress. Some believe the accident was exacerbated by incorrect decisions made because the operators were overwhelmed with too much information. Some believe it was operator error, without regard for the data. Much of the information from the sensors was irrelevant, misleading, or incorrect.

After the TMI incident, nuclear reactor operator training changed. Before TMI, operator training focused on diagnosing the underlying problem, apparently with bad data. Afterwards, the training focused on reacting to the emergency by going through a standardized checklist to ensure that the core is receiving enough coolant. The key is: You've got to keep the core cool. In my opinion, this is the opposite of thinking out of the box, but in some scenarios; thinking out of the box might not be the best thing. The Monkey Checklist, sometimes, might be a good thing.

It took the operators 16 hours to realize they had a major problem, because they had too much information. Right, wrong, or indifferent; they had too much information.

Too much information is something to think about. Sometimes, it's not a good thing.

Posted: 18:56
Category: Observations
Pings: 0
Comments

.. sounds like a good time, Sam... I've always wanted to get hammered near a nuclear power plant... the possibilites are endless....

Posted by: Eric at May 5, 2005 08:11 AM

The Three Mile Island "disaster" is mostly a myth. It COULD have been bad, but it wasn't. Nobody was killed or injured, but panic-freaks blew everything all out of proportion and basically managed to shut down the construction of nuke power plants in this country.

I spent a great deal of my life operating boilers and power plants. I never ran a nuke facility, but the principles are the same. The fail-safes worked at Three Mile Island. Most people don't know how over-engineered those places are.

You have to TRY to fuck it up. And even then, you have to try HARD.

Posted by: Acidman at May 5, 2005 02:29 PM

They had too much BAD information. Led to BAD decisions. Thing should have been over in 45 minutes.

Posted by: Velociman at May 5, 2005 10:32 PM

I'll be at the Hershey Hotel next month with a bunch of wild and crazy ::ciough:: lawyers. I know who the one or two are who like cocktails, so it should be OK.

Posted by: Jim - PRS at May 5, 2005 10:49 PM

I live near there. TMI isn't quite in my backyard, but close. I suppose it's just one of those things you learn to live with. But it is rather unnerving to fly in to the airport OVER TMI.

I've been to TMI, but never to Hotel Hershey...what is up with that?

Posted by: Amy at May 7, 2005 08:40 AM
Post a comment












Remember personal info?





 
Links
Credits
Powered by Movable Type

Site design by Sekimori

Hosted by Hostmatters.com